MLB The Show 25: How to MLB The Show 25 Stubs Rebuild the AL East in Franchise Mode

If you're diving into MLB The Show 25's Franchise Mode and aiming to rebuild a team, the AL East is a great but challenging place to start. This division is stacked with powerhouse organizations and historic rivalries, meaning a successful rebuild here must be sharp, patient, and strategic.

In this guide, I'll walk you through how to rebuild each of the five AL East teams using a categorization system that helps determine who to build around, who to trade, and which prospects should be part of your long-term plans.

Rebuild Strategy: Player Categories

Before jumping into each team, here's a quick explanation of the player evaluation system used:

Long-Term Pros (Under Team Control)

Franchise Players (1)- Elite, face-of-the-franchise stars worth building around with a 10+ year window.
Stars (2)- Top-100 league-wide players. Every contender needs a few.
Long-Term Core (3)- Solid starters or everyday players for at least three seasons.
Pros With Potential (4)- May evolve into long-term pieces or solid bench options.
Bench/Bubble MLB (5)- Depth guys; useful but replaceable.

Short-Term Veterans

Short-Term/Trade Bait (1S)- Valuable now but likely gone in a few years; ideal trade chips.
Low-End Pros (2S)- Replacement-level players; fine temporarily, but upgrade soon.
Liability Veterans (3S)- Overpaid or underperforming players locked into your roster.
Minor League Vets (4S)- AAA depth and buy MLB The Show 25 Stubs emergency backup options.